The scrap value of a hacked PC
Summary
Brian Krebs visualises how criminals turn almost every part of a compromised computer, its identity and its network connection into money. The graphic updated an earlier piece Krebs did for the Washington Post. The new version added ransomware as a way of cashing in.
Ideas
- A computer remains economically valuable to attackers even without online banking.
- Computing power and bandwidth can be rented out for spam, click fraud and attacks.
- Stored accounts enable identity theft and the takeover of further services.
- Ransomware turns local data directly into a means of extortion.
- Social reputation has a resale value of its own.
- Criminal markets break compromised systems down into resources that are traded separately.
Insights
- Low personal data value does not mean low value to an attacker.
- Cybercrime scales by marketing technical resources in a division of labour.
- Defence starts with a realistic model of the adversary’s incentives.
Quotes
Nearly every aspect of a hacked computer and a user’s online life can be commoditized.
– Brian Krebs
Habits
- Krebs translates the abstract underground economy into an understandable diagram for everyday users.
Facts
- Hijacked social media profiles were also listed as tradable assets.
References
- Brian Krebs: The Scrap Value of a Hacked PC, Revisited
- Tools for a Safer PC: additional protection guide from KrebsOnSecurity.
Critique
- The graphic simplifies prices and roles in a criminal market that is constantly changing.
- Specific ways of cashing in from 2012 do not fully match today’s threat landscape.
Remarks
- The argument still refutes the sentence: there is nothing to get from me.
- Cloud accounts and session tokens would expand a current version considerably.
Recommendations
- Protect even seemingly unimportant devices consistently.
- Separate accounts, sessions and administrative rights according to their damage potential.
- Explain security measures in terms of concrete attacker incentives.
Links to the original source and the Web Archive open in a new tab.