bk99.de entertain the web since 1997

bk99.de
RFC · Internet cultureStandard explained

RFC 8890: The internet is for end users

Summary

RFC 8890 states as a guideline that internet standards should prioritise the benefit and self-determination of end users. Protocol design is never completely value-neutral. Open networks only stay open if user interests are explicitly represented.

Ideas

  • Technical decisions distribute power between users and intermediaries.
  • User interests can differ from the interests of operators or providers.
  • Standards should consider their effects on real people.

Remarks

  • RFC 8890 is an informational document and not an Internet Standard.

Recommendations

  • Assess architectural decisions from the perspective of the affected users.
  • Document shifts of power, not just technical efficiency.

References

Read the RFC at the RFC Editor

Search the Web Archive

RFC · 1993

RFC 1459: IRC: Open real-time communication

RFC 1459 documents the Internet Relay Chat protocol for federated servers, channels and direct messages. Simple text protocols can carry communities for decades. Federation distributes operations but requires shared conventions.

RFC · 1990

RFC 1149: IP over carrier pigeons

RFC 1149 humorously describes the transport of IP datagrams by carrier pigeons and was later actually tried out. April Fools’ jokes can convey protocol properties surprisingly clearly. Bandwidth and latency are independent quantities.

HN · 2011

CmdrTaco leaves SD

Rob Malda says goodbye to SD and looks back on fourteen years of an early, community-moderated technology platform. Online communities depend on software, rules and credible cultural leadership at the same time. A founder's departure tests whether a platform was carried by an institution or by a person.