bk99.de entertain the web since 1997

bk99.de
CCC · Digital societyCurated

We Lost the War: Acting after the loss of digital innocence

Summary

Rop Gonggrijp and Frank Rieger analyse the foreseeable loss of privacy and civil rights and look for effective answers beyond technical resignation. A lost battle can clarify the strategy without ending the whole conflict. Infrastructure decisions become civil rights issues as soon as they make behaviour permanently observable.

Ideas

  • Ubiquitous data collection changes power relations more permanently than individual surveillance laws.
  • Technical convenience can quietly weaken society’s ability to exercise control.
  • Lost privacy cannot be regained through better individual tools alone.
  • Resignation helps those who present surveillance as inevitable.
  • Technical communities must explain the political consequences of their systems in an understandable way.
  • Effective resistance needs realistic goals instead of nostalgic ideas of going back.

Insights

  • A pessimistic diagnosis and an attitude ready for action do not exclude each other.

Quotes

  • Come to terms with the imminent loss of privacy and civil rights without going lethargic. – talk description

Habits

  • Gonggrijp and Rieger link technical trends to their long-term social consequences.

References

  • CCC: We lost the war
  • 22C3: Private Investigations (the event of the talk).
  • Rop Gonggrijp and Frank Rieger: speakers.

Critique

  • The deliberately drastic diagnosis underestimates later technical and legal countermovements.
  • Some predictions reflect the threat models of 2005.

Remarks

  • The title became a recurring reference within hacker culture.
  • A ten-year review at 32C3 re-examined many of the theses from back then.

Recommendations

  • Also assess new infrastructure by its consequences for power and civil rights.
  • Combine technical protection with political and legal work.
  • Formulate achievable counter-strategies, even if complete avoidance seems impossible.

Watch the talk

Search the Web Archive

CCC · 2012

Railuino: Controlling Märklin digital with Arduino

Jörg Pleumann replaces expensive Märklin control units with Arduino, CAN bus and inexpensive connection boxes to control a digital model railway openly. Understanding an existing bus can replace proprietary control units with small adapters. A toy becomes an open automation platform as soon as its protocol becomes accessible.

CCC · 2026

MeshCore on 868 MHz: A decentralised radio network without the internet

Christian Stankowic and CodeSalat show how MeshCore and Meshtastic enable independent text networks and custom mesh bots with inexpensive LoRa hardware. Both projects build decentralised text networks on LoRa radio technology. Under suitable conditions, messages can cover many kilometres across several nodes.

CCC · 2026

Self-hosting email: DNS, spam filters and reputation

davd delivers a reality check on running your own mail server and explains why DNS, deliverability, spam defence and reputation are harder than the actual server software. With email, self-hosting fails more often because of social trust than because of SMTP. Decentralisation only survives if small operators can achieve deliverability in practice.